There’s something cozy and enchanting about stepping into a thrift store. The faint scent of well-loved books, the glint of vintage glassware on wooden shelves, the quiet rustle of hangers sliding along a metal rack—it’s not just shopping; it’s discovery. Each store holds its own kind of magic, a curated chaos of the past waiting to find new life in the hands of someone who sees its charm.
For many, thrifting isn’t just a budget-friendly habit—it’s a lifestyle. A rebellion against fast fashion. A hunt for one-of-a-kind treasures. And in Southern Colorado, that adventure takes on a whole new meaning.
And it’s not just seasoned collectors making the rounds. Younger generations are redefining what it means to shop with intention. According to a 2023 ThredUp Resale Report, 83% of Gen Z and 85% of Millennials have either purchased or are open to purchasing secondhand, fueling a market projected to reach $70 billion by 2027.
If you’re on the hunt for retro threads, vintage furniture, or simply an afternoon of wandering, this guide to the most beloved thrift spots across Florence, Cañon City, and Pueblo will take you there.
FLORENCE
Florence Flipping Peddler
An antique and thrift store offering vintage books, a small library, and a vendor market with a wide variety of new and used items.
118 W Main St, Florence
(719) 799-0982
FlorenceFlippingPeddler.com
Manna House Resale Shop
A non-profit organization dedicated to helping those in need with compassion and dignity, offering a range of secondhand items.
115 E Main St, Florence
(719) 784-1955
FlorenceMannaHouse.org
Trending on Main
An eclectic boutique offering a mix of antique and modern home décor, furniture, and gift items. Perfect for those seeking unique pieces to add character to their spaces.
111 W Main St, Florence
(630) 292-2472
Facebook: Trending On Main
CAÑON CITY
Autumn’s Attic
A delightful shop filled with antiques and collectibles, offering a nostalgic shopping experience for treasure hunters.
431 Main St, Cañon City
(719) 429-7900
Facebook: Autumns Attic Cañon City
Chrysalis Consignments
Specializing in women’s fashion, this classy consignment shop features a wide range of clothing, accessories, and jewelry, with new items arriving regularly.
515 Main St, Cañon City
(719) 275-5530
ChrysalisConsignments.com
Gift of Thrift Charity
A non-profit organization dedicated to providing affordable second-hand goods, supporting charitable causes within the community.
923 Main St, Cañon City
(719) 458-1018
Facebook: Gift of Thrift Charity Store
Goodwill Store & Donation Center
Offering a vast selection of clothing, home goods, and more, with proceeds supporting employment programs and community services.
910 Main St, Cañon City
(719) 275-7160
GoodwillColorado.org
New Horizons Thrift Store
A clean and organized store featuring clothing, furniture, and household items, known for its friendly staff and great deals.
3170 E Main St, Cañon City
(719) 276-2676
NewHorizonsThriftStores.com
COLORADO SPRINGS
Arc Thrift Stores
A Colorado staple, Arc Thrift stores offer a wide selection of gently used clothing, furniture, and household items. Proceeds support individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities.
Multiple Locations in Colorado Springs, including:
1830 W Uintah St. • (719) 473-0502
2780 S Academy Blvd. • (719) 391-7717
7207 N Academy Blvd. • (719) 528-5263
4402 Austin Bluffs Pkwy. • (719) 522-1203
ArcThrift.com
Ashley’s Attic
A charming women’s resale boutique located in a historic Victorian home, offering unique and affordable fashion curated by a mother-daughter duo.
708 N Weber St, Colorado Springs
(719) 237-1323
AshleysAtticCOS.com
Bargain Box Thrift Store
Operated by the Assistance League of Colorado Springs, this thrift store supports local philanthropic programs, offering quality merchandise including apparel, books and home décor.
405 S Nevada Ave, Colorado Springs
(719) 475-1029
AssistanceLeague.org/colorado-springs
Life Network Family Thrift Store
A bright and organized store offering a wide selection of quality items, with proceeds supporting Life Network’s outreach programs.
5406 N Academy Blvd, Colorado Springs
(719) 344-9904
LifeNetworkThrift.com
Sisters’ Thrift & Boutique
A unique boutique offering upscale used clothing, household goods, and handmade items, with proceeds supporting the Benet Hill Monastery.
8674 N Union Blvd, Colorado Springs
(719) 282-0316
BenetHillMonastery.org
The Hause Thrift & Lounge
Located inside Chapel Hills Mall, this thrift and vintage store offers a curated selection of clothing, shoes, vinyl records, and more, creating a unique shopping experience.
1710 Briargate Blvd, Suite 707, COS
750 Citadel Dr E Suite 2206, COS
(719) 594-0111
TheHauseCollective.com
Uptown Cheapskate North Academy
A trendy resale store buying and selling stylish, gently used clothing and accessories for young adults, offering affordable fashion options.
5915 N Academy Blvd, Suite 5917-A COS
(719) 203-472
UptownCheapskate.com
PUEBLO
Arc Thrift Store
A non-profit store offering a wide range of items, with proceeds benefiting individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities.
1115 S Prairie Ave., Pueblo
(719) 564-9491
ArcThrift.com
Bargain Box Thrift Store
Operated by the Assistance League of Pueblo, this volunteer-run store supports local philanthropic programs through its sales.
1112 Pueblo Blvd Way, Pueblo
(719) 543-1383
AssistanceLeaguePueblo.org
Boyer Brothers Second Hand
A local establishment specializing in affordable and unique second-hand items, catering to budget-conscious shoppers.
1123 S Prairie Ave., Pueblo
(719) 493-5958
Boyer-Brothers-Second-Hand.hub.biz
Ffmsog Thrift & More
A lesser-known gem in Pueblo offering a wide variety of goods for thrifters looking to explore new spots.
1721 S Prairie Ave., Pueblo
(719) 242-0882
Goodwill Store & Donation Center
A well-known destination for a variety of second-hand goods, supporting job training and community programs.
3610 Dillon Dr., Pueblo
(719) 545-0173
GoodwillColorado.org
New Horizons Thrift Store
Offering a clean shopping environment with a wide selection of items, known for its commitment to quality and community support.
2930 N Elizabeth St., Pueblo
(719) 276-2676
NewHorizonsThriftStores.com
The Golden Needle and Treasures
A unique shop offering a variety of items, known for its personalized service and eclectic selection.
1818 Santa Fe Dr., Pueblo • (719) 545-8877
The Golden Needle Treasures
